Level 1 · Module 3: Spending and Choosing · Lesson 5

The Feeling of Wanting vs the Feeling of Having

reflectionvalue-exchange-pricebuilding-owning-risking

The feeling of wanting something is usually much bigger and more exciting than the feeling of finally having it. Most people spend their whole lives chasing the wanting feeling and getting confused when the having feeling is quieter than they expected. Knowing this does not ruin anything — it just lets you stop chasing things that were never going to feel the way you thought.

Building On

Impulse and patience

Two lessons ago we learned to pause before buying. This lesson explains part of why the pause matters — the rush you feel BEFORE buying is often bigger than the joy you feel AFTER. Waiting is a way of checking whether the rush was the real thing or just the feeling of wanting.

Why It Matters

This is probably the single most useful idea in the whole module, and almost no kid is ever told it out loud. The wanting feeling is loud. It lights up your chest and your mind and makes a toy or a game or a snack feel like the most important thing in the world. You imagine how happy you will be when you have it. You picture yourself holding it. The picture in your head is huge and glowing.

The having feeling is smaller. Not always — sometimes a thing really does make you happy for a long time — but often, surprisingly often, the excitement fades fast. The toy becomes just another toy. The game becomes just a game. The snack tastes good for about ninety seconds and then it is gone. You look up and you are the same person you were before you had it.

This gap — between how big the wanting feels and how quiet the having turns out to be — is one of the main things that fools grown-ups for their entire lives. They keep buying things because the wanting feeling promises them a having feeling that never quite shows up. They try bigger things, nicer things, more expensive things, hoping one of them will finally match the size of the wanting. It almost never does. The wanting is the big thing. The having is a smaller, quieter thing that has to grow over time.

If you notice this early, two things happen. First, you stop being surprised when a new thing does not make you as happy as you thought it would. Second, you stop needing to buy as much, because you know the wanting feeling is not a trustworthy guide to how the having will actually feel. You start to trust things that do give a steady having feeling — the book you read three times, the toy you still play with a month later, the friend you still want to see — and you notice the difference.

A Story

The Night Before and the Morning After

For two months, all Isaac could think about was a new video game. Every day at school, his friends talked about it. Every night, he watched videos of other kids playing it. He imagined, over and over, what it would feel like to finally have it. In his imagination, he was never bored. He was always just about to play the game.

The game cost forty dollars. Isaac saved for six weeks, doing extra chores and saving his birthday money and not buying anything else. The night before his family was going to the store to buy it, he could barely sleep. He lay in bed picturing the box on his shelf. He pictured holding the controller. He pictured the look on his friends’ faces when he told them. His chest felt warm and full.

‘This is going to be the best thing that has ever happened to me,’ he whispered into the dark.

The next day, he bought the game. On the way home he held the box in his lap like it was a small glowing treasure. His mom smiled at him in the rearview mirror, because she recognized that feeling from somewhere very far back in her own life.

He played the game the whole afternoon. It was good. It was really good. At first, it was every bit as good as he had hoped. Around dinner, his mom had to call him three times before he stopped. He ate fast and went back.

By the second day, the game was still fun. He beat a hard level and felt proud.

By the fourth day, the game was fun for maybe an hour and then he noticed he was a little bored. He had been playing the same kinds of levels for a while and they had stopped feeling surprising.

By the next weekend, the game sat on the shelf for a day and a half before he even picked it up. When he did, he enjoyed it, but the magic feeling from the night before he bought it was nowhere. That feeling had been bigger than anything playing the actual game could match.

A month later, Isaac was at his grandfather’s house, and his grandfather asked him about the game. Isaac had to think for a second to remember whether he had played it that week.

‘Is it a bad game?’ his grandfather asked.

‘No, it’s a great game,’ Isaac said. ‘It’s just… the wanting was bigger than the having. When I was about to get it, I felt like it was going to change everything. Now I have it. Everything is exactly the same.’

His grandfather nodded slowly, as if Isaac had just said something that took most people decades to notice. ‘That is one of the most important things you will ever learn, kid. Most people never learn it. They just keep buying bigger things, trying to make the having feeling match the wanting feeling, and wondering why it never does.’

‘Is the wanting feeling bad, then?’ Isaac asked.

‘No. It’s just not what it pretends to be. It pretends to be a promise. Really, it’s just a feeling. Sometimes the thing you want is worth getting anyway. Sometimes it isn’t. But you should never trust the wanting to tell you which one.’

Vocabulary

Anticipation: The feeling of waiting for something you really want. Anticipation is often bigger than the thing itself — so big that it can fool you into thinking the thing will feel just as big.
Wanting: The eager, excited feeling you have when you don’t yet have the thing. Wanting is loud and usually larger than life.
Having: The quieter feeling you have once the thing is actually yours. Having is usually smaller than wanting — but sometimes grows over time if the thing is the right kind of thing.
Letdown: The small sinking feeling when you notice that having a thing did not feel as big as wanting it did. A letdown is not proof you made a bad choice — it is just information.
Hedonic: A fancy word that just means ‘about feelings and pleasure.’ You don’t need this word yet. It’s only here because when you’re older you’ll hear grown-ups say ‘hedonic treadmill,’ and when you do, you’ll already know what they mean.

Guided Teaching

I want to tell you something that almost nobody will tell you when you’re your age, and yet it is one of the truest things in the world. The feeling of wanting a thing is almost always bigger than the feeling of finally having that thing. Not sometimes. Almost always.

Close your eyes and try to remember something you really, really wanted last year or the year before. A toy. A game. A gadget. An outfit. Picture how badly you wanted it. Now think about where that thing is right now. Is it still giving you a big feeling? Or is it mostly sitting around, not thought about, kind of normal?

Ask your child: was there ever a toy or game or thing you were dying to have, and then a few weeks later it just felt… regular? Can you tell me about one?

This is not a trick. It is not even rare. It happens to almost everything you buy, except for a small number of things that turn out to keep mattering. The wanting feeling is huge and glowing. The having feeling starts smaller and then either shrinks (for most things) or slowly grows stronger and quieter (for the few things you really love).

Grown-ups have a phrase for this — they call it the ‘hedonic treadmill.’ You do not need to remember the phrase. You just need to remember the shape of it. People get a thing, feel good for a little while, and then get used to it. The good feeling fades. They look around for the next thing to want, and the wanting feeling comes back again, huge and glowing, promising them that this time, finally, the having will match it. And it almost never does. Then they look for the next thing. And the next. A treadmill. Always moving, never arriving.

Here is the key sentence: the wanting feeling is not a promise. It is just a feeling. It tells you what you want. It does not tell you how happy the thing will make you.

Now, this does not mean you should stop buying things. That would be silly. Some things are worth the cost, and some things really do keep giving you the having feeling for months or years. What this means is that you should not trust the wanting to tell you which ones those are. The wanting is too loud. It will promise you big feelings about everything. You have to slow down and ask a different question.

The question is: ‘in a month, will I still care about this?’ That question is a much better guide than ‘how much do I want this right now?’ The second one is always lying.

Some things pass the month test. A book you will reread. A tool you will use. A toy you will play with every day for weeks. A game you will still be thinking about. Most things do not pass the month test. Most things are all wanting and very little having. You get to learn which is which, one purchase at a time, if you pay attention.

Pattern to Notice

For the next few weeks, try this quiet experiment. When you notice yourself really wanting something, write it down on a little piece of paper with today’s date. You don’t have to stop wanting it. You don’t have to decide anything. Just write it down. Then, a month later, look at the paper and ask yourself: do I still want this? If you got it, is it still making me happy? Do this with five or ten things and you will start to see a pattern that most grown-ups never see.

A Good Response

A child who learns this well does not become cynical or joyless. The opposite happens: they stop chasing things that were never going to satisfy them, and they start valuing the things that actually do — the books they reread, the toys that last, the people they keep wanting to be with. They can still want things. They can still be excited. But they notice the difference between excitement and evidence, and they stop mistaking one for the other. This is one of those lessons that, if it lands, will quietly make their whole life easier.

Moral Thread

Self-awareness

Self-awareness is not an abstract, mushy thing. It is the practical skill of noticing what you actually feel instead of what you assumed you would feel. People who can do this make better decisions about everything, not just money. People who cannot do it spend their whole lives chasing feelings that never show up when the thing arrives.

Misuse Warning

Be careful not to teach this in a way that makes your child think wanting is shameful or that being excited about something is childish. It is not. Wanting is human, and the excitement is real. The lesson is not ‘don’t want things.’ The lesson is ‘don’t believe everything the wanting tells you about how happy you will be.’ Also watch out for kids who use this idea to mock other people: ‘you just think you want that, you don’t really.’ That is not kindness and it is not wisdom. A person is allowed to want their own thing without being lectured by someone who just learned about the having feeling this morning. The lesson is for your own reflection, not for policing anyone else’s excitement.

For Discussion

1.In the story, what did Isaac feel the night before he got the game? What did he feel a month after?
2.Can you think of something you really, really wanted — and now you’ve had it long enough to know how the having feels? What’s the difference?
3.Why do you think the wanting feeling is almost always bigger than the having feeling?
4.Does this mean you should stop wanting things? Why or why not?
5.What is the ‘month test,’ and why is it a better question than ‘how badly do I want this right now?’
6.What are some things in your life that have actually kept making you happy for a long time? What’s different about them?
7.If the wanting feeling is not a reliable promise, what IS it? What is it actually telling you?

Practice

The Wanting Journal

1.Get a small notebook or a single piece of paper and keep it somewhere you can find it again in a month.
2.For the next week, whenever you feel a strong ‘I really want that’ feeling — about anything — write it down with the date. Do not decide whether to buy it. Just write it down. Aim for at least five entries.
3.Next to each entry, on a scale of one to ten, write how big the wanting feeling is right now. Ten means ‘this is all I can think about.’ One means ‘mild.’
4.Put the paper somewhere safe. Do not look at it for a month.
5.When a month has passed, pull the paper out with a parent. For each item, ask yourself: do I still want it? If I got it, does it still feel like it did in my head? Was the wanting feeling accurate or much bigger than the reality? Talk it over together.

Memory Questions

1.Which feeling is usually bigger — wanting a thing or having a thing?
2.In the story, what did Isaac say to his grandfather about the game after a month?
3.Does this lesson mean you should stop wanting things? Explain.
4.What is the ‘month test’?
5.If the wanting feeling is not a promise, what is it?
6.Name one kind of thing that usually DOES keep making people happy for a long time. Why do you think that is?

A Note for Parents

This is the most psychologically important lesson in the entire module, and also the easiest one to accidentally turn into a downer. Be very careful not to make it sound like wanting is bad, or that your child should feel guilty about ever getting excited about things. That would completely miss the point. The point is self-knowledge: noticing the gap between expected feelings and actual feelings, and letting that knowledge make better decisions the next time, without shame. A common trap: parents use this lesson as a new weapon to say ‘I told you the toy wouldn’t make you happy.’ Please do not do this. If your child has a letdown after a purchase, the letdown is the teacher, and your job is to sit next to them and help them notice it — not to score a point. Another trap: kids who are naturally reflective will sometimes take this lesson too far and develop a quiet suspicion of all their own excitements, which looks like wisdom but is actually anxiety. If you see that, reassure them that the wanting feeling is still part of being alive and that being excited is not a failure of judgment. The skill is noticing the feeling, not fighting it. The Wanting Journal exercise is especially good because it externalizes the reflection — the paper holds the evidence, so the child doesn’t have to argue with themselves in the moment.

Share This Lesson

Found this useful? Pass it along to another family walking the same road.